19 Nov
2014
19 Nov
'14
9:42 p.m.
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA224
I see no reason to take something off list that I did
not bring onto the
list.
You say you are not complaining, if using the adjective awful is not a
complaint about the usability of Mint/MATE what is it?
I genuinely have no problem with what you have pointed out, I do however
feel you go overboard.
Like I said in my first response to this topic I see alot of TDE is
"wonderful" (which is great) but everything else is "awful".
When you use something, and by your own admission you use Mint/MATE, and
you find a problem with it it really does help others if you tell the
people who are developing it. Your reply certainly indicates you never did
this so to be fair your complaint isn't really helpful. Do you report
problems you find with TDE? If you find something I bet you would because
you have an emotional attachment to TDE but you don't have an emotional
attachment to anything else and because of this it appears as though it is
fine for you to bag them.
I find that extremely unfair and unreasonable especially when you wont
take
the time to help projects you do use.
While I largely agree with the ideas posted above, bear in mind that many
projects/products (both open-source and commercial) have a definite idea
of what they want their user experience to be, and any attempt at
deviation will result in (at minimum) wasted effort on the part of the
"bug" reporter or possibly even devolution to name calling, belittling,
etc. on lists. Fortunately I have not seen much of the latter but I have
had numerous UX bugs immediately tagged as WONTFIX or just plain ignored
by large upstream projects; this has dissuaded me from bothering to report
them in the first place as I can generally spend the same amount of
overall time adding a feature to TDE or coding a workaround for something
missing.
Molding existing projects to your UX desires is often not feasible. Even
this project (and I myself) have rejected numerous UX proposals that are
outside the spirit of TDE's design.
TL;DR: Find something that's 90% of the way to where you like it and
support it no matter what. Forget about molding something that's 50%
there into what you want.
Just my $0.02. :-)
Tim
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----
Version: GnuPG v1.4.11 (GNU/Linux)
iFYEARELAAYFAlRtDqoACgkQLaxZSoRZrGEG6gDfeHdwhgWnKczdQNI1JgdDzVXw
ZjDbMdhPfnSm6QDgyysPpyZtbqNo2HMxTwnJLGc2pk0TBDpee2Mz5A==
=4neh
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----