On Thu, Oct 29, 2020 at 02:51:00PM +0100, Gerhard Zintel wrote:
So please, please trim down your answers to the
necessary amount as long as
bottom-posting is the policy of this list.
Seconded! Please trim! Kmail makes it easy by default: select the text
you want to remove, and press the backspace or delete key.
But bottom posting is not the policy of this list. The list policy is to
**avoid top posting**, with either bottom or *inline* posting preferred.
See the "Mailing List Etiquette" section here:
http://www.trinitydesktop.org/mailinglist.php
Personally, I think that the bottom posting without trimming is even
ruder than top-posting. You still have pages and pages of historical
posts duplicated in the message, but instead of it being underneath your
reply where nobody needs to look at it, bottom-posting forces people to
scroll through it looking for comments.
The worst case I have ever seen, in an email thread I cared enough about
to keep reading, was (by memory) *forty-seven* screen fulls of quoted
text for a single one-line comment at the end. Not on this list though.
I worked out at the time that, had it been printed out on paper, that
would have been something like thirty full A4 pages of quoted text, with
the deepest quote something like 15 or 16 levels:
> > > > > > > > > > >
> > > blah blah blah
(One should trim inline posting too. It's very rare for any quote more
than 4 or 5 levels deep to still be relevent in the discussion, people
can always look at the web archive if the need the full history of the
thread.)
--
Steve