Hello,
When I launch an application, Trinity proposes to keep the root password during 120 min. I anwswer yes with the radio button.
But the next time, Trinity did not keep the password in memory and I have to retype it.
Thank you and have a good day.
André
andre_debian@numericable.fr wrote:
But the next time, Trinity did not keep the password in memory and I have to retype it.
As far as I am aware it is not a session thing. I'm not 100% sure, but if you leave the application open it does not ask. Only if you close the app and open again.
perhaps you could open a proper bug so that it may get developers attention and can be answered properly.
regards
On Friday 19 May 2017 17:20:00 deloptes wrote:
andre_debian@numericable.fr wrote:
But the next time, Trinity did not keep the password in memory and I have to retype it.
As far as I am aware it is not a session thing. I'm not 100% sure, but if you leave the application open it does not ask. Only if you close the app and open again. perhaps you could open a proper bug so that it may get developers attention and can be answered properly. regards
The window proposes me to store the root password in memory, and after, for all root applications, I don't have to retype this password during 120 min, even if the application is closed.
I open another root application before the 120 min, but I have to retype the password.
Thanks,
André
On Friday 19 May 2017 23.05:58 andre_debian@numericable.fr wrote:
The window proposes me to store the root password in memory, and after, for all root applications, I don't have to retype this password during 120 min, even if the application is closed.
I open another root application before the 120 min, but I have to retype the password.
Hello André,
I have the same behaviour. However, after some trial, I come to the following conclusion: the message sould be understood as: "for 120 minutes you won't have to enter the root password again *for the application you have just given root rights*, not *for all applications*.
When I tried, I got this behaviour:
open synaptic - asked give root password - ticked the option to keep it - enter root password
open gparted- asked give root password
open root terminal- asked give root password
open synaptic- no password asked - closed synaptic
open- no password asked - closed synaptic
So I think it's not a bug, it's a missunderstanding of the message's meaning (or maybe we could ask the message to say "kept for up to 120 minutes for this app"
Regards,
Thierry
On Saturday 20 May 2017 09:23:21 Thierry de Coulon wrote:
On Friday 19 May 2017 23.05:58 andre_debian@numericable.fr wrote:
The window proposes me to store the root password in memory, and after, for all root applications, I don't have to retype this password during 120 min, even if the application is closed. I open another root application before the 120 min, but I have to retype the password.
Hello André, I have the same behaviour. However, after some trial, I come to the following conclusion: the message sould be understood as: "for 120 minutes you won't have to enter the root password again *for the application you have just given root rights*, not *for all applications*. When I tried, I got this behaviour: open synaptic - asked give root password - ticked the option to keep it - enter root password open gparted- asked give root password open root terminal- asked give root password open synaptic- no password asked - closed synaptic open- no password asked - closed synaptic So I think it's not a bug, it's a missunderstanding of the message's meaning (or maybe we could ask the message to say "kept for up to 120 minutes for this app" Regards, Thierry
Thanks Thierry.
To be sure to understand, I join the graphic message that I receive. Sorry, it's in french (the 6 first lines) :
Translation : Run as root TDE su This action requires the rights of the super administrator, fill the password... Keep in memory the password ?
and after it's in english...
Maybe you are right but the message is not clear and leads to confusion.
Happy day,
André
andre_debian@numericable.fr wrote:
On Saturday 20 May 2017 09:23:21 Thierry de Coulon wrote:
On Friday 19 May 2017 23.05:58 andre_debian@numericable.fr wrote:
The window proposes me to store the root password in memory, and after, for all root applications, I don't have to retype this password during 120 min, even if the application is closed. I open another root application before the 120 min, but I have to retype the password.
Hello André, I have the same behaviour. However, after some trial, I come to the following conclusion: the message sould be understood as: "for 120 minutes you won't have to enter the root password again *for the application you have just given root rights*, not *for all applications*. When I tried, I got this behaviour: open synaptic - asked give root password - ticked the option to keep it - enter root password open gparted- asked give root password open root terminal- asked give root password open synaptic- no password asked - closed synaptic open- no password asked - closed synaptic So I think it's not a bug, it's a missunderstanding of the message's meaning (or maybe we could ask the message to say "kept for up to 120 minutes for this app" Regards, Thierry
Thanks Thierry.
To be sure to understand, I join the graphic message that I receive. Sorry, it's in french (the 6 first lines) :
Translation : Run as root TDE su This action requires the rights of the super administrator, fill the password... Keep in memory the password ?
and after it's in english...
Maybe you are right but the message is not clear and leads to confusion.
Happy day,
André
Andre, as Thierry said, please open a bug and ask for changing the message, so that it says * Kept for up to 120 minutes for this application
regards
On Saturday 20 May 2017 12:50:11 deloptes wrote:
andre_debian@numericable.fr wrote:
On Saturday 20 May 2017 09:23:21 Thierry de Coulon wrote:
So I think it's not a bug, it's a missunderstanding of the message's
Andre, as Thierry said, please open a bug and ask for changing the message, so that it says
- Kept for up to 120 minutes for this application
Why open a bug, because Thierry said : "So I think it's not a bug, it's a missunderstanding..."
And how or where open a bug ?
I'm lucky, what happens now... a miracle ? the store root password works fine, I open a root application, the password is asked one time, and not the next time during two hours.
Good night,
André
andre_debian@numericable.fr wrote:
Why open a bug, because Thierry said : "So I think it's not a bug, it's a missunderstanding..."
And how or where open a bug ?
I'm lucky, what happens now... a miracle ? the store root password works fine, I open a root application, the password is asked one time, and not the next time during two hours.
if you want to get change into the code, the way is through a bug/ticket in the bug tracking system. Even if you create a patch and want this patch to be pushed to the code it goes via bug ticket. Bug as meant by Thierry means a problem - defect. In the bug tracking system you can request improvement - in your case the label of the password prompt.
https://bugs.trinitydesktop.org/
The link is on the official TDE web site.
regards
-
andre_debian＠numericable.fr -
deloptes -
Thierry de Coulon